
Warrantless government spying: Republicans want to renew FISA 702 during lame duck
Despite the rhetoric we’ve been hearing out of Republicans in Washington in the past, a push to renew FISA Section 702 is likely to occur during the 30 working days remaining in the lame duck session of Congress, thus ensuring that the warrantless government spying we’ve come to know since 9/11 will continue.
Originally set to expire on April 20, 2026, the deadline for FISA 702 renewal was extended to April 30, but that deadline came and went without passage, despite efforts by “conservative” Republicans like Senator Mike Lee to pass the SAFE Act — a band-aid meant to buy Republicans time to pass a clean renewal at a later date. Thankfully, neither FISA Section 702 nor the SAFE Act was passed at the time . . . and for good reason according to op-ed by Patrick Eddington, a senior fellow in homeland security and civil liberties at the Cato Institute:
The countdown on a key U.S. surveillance capability has begun, with Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) set to expire on April 20 absent its reauthorization by Congress. We should let it. Originally sold to the public as a counterterrorism-related surveillance response to the 9/11 attacks, the Section 702 program has morphed into far more than a “foreign intelligence information” collection tool. And recent efforts to reform, rather than repeal, the legislation fall short.
Section 702 authorizes the National Security Agency (NSA) to collect communications of non-U.S. persons located abroad without a warrant. However, because of the structure of the global telecommunications system, the text messages, phone calls, and other digital data of people in the United States are invariably captured during FISA Section 702 collection activities. That information is stored in databases that are queried by the NSA, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and even some Central Intelligence Agency personnel—all without having to obtain a warrant from a federal judge before conducting such searches. The prior abuses of such Section 702 collection and warrantless database querying are well documented.
[Recently], a bipartisan group of senators introduced a 116-page bill—the Security and Freedom Enhancement (SAFE) Act—ostensibly designed to bring an end to nearly 20 years of constitutional rights violations under Section 702. But the legislation includes several fatal flaws, potentially allowing for the continuation of warrantless searches and unrestricted data collection targeting Americans. (Emphasis mine)
Following November’s blue tsunami, statists in both parties have come to the realization that passing FISA Section 702 in its current form next year will be a tougher task after Democrats seize the reins of power. For example, House Intelligence Ranking Member Jim Himes (D-CT) — apparently a big fan of the Republican version of the bill — is openly inviting Republicans to cram a clean FISA Section 702 renewal down America’s throat during the Lame Duck session (via The Hill):
Rep. Jim Himes (D-Conn.), the top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, said Republicans would be wise to renew the nation’s warrantless spy powers during the lame-duck session.
“I made it clear to some very senior administration officials that they should get this thing done in the lame-duck because it’s, you know, it’s going to be a very different 702 that gets reauthorized in the first quarter of next year, and, you know, I think they heard the message,” the lawmaker told The Hill.
“And I wasn’t even saying that’s good or bad. I’m just saying it’s a political reality that the 702 that gets reauthorized with a Democratic House and Senate is going to be a very different 702 that gets reauthorized in the lame-duck,” he continued.
“I just asked them to think about that because, you know, they’ve been screwing around,” Himes added. “The administration’s been screwing around and deprioritizing this issue, even though it’s, you know, exposing them to huge risk.”
The Republican-led House passed a bill to renew FISA 702 with limited reforms, but it has lingered in the Senate, which is working on its own bill but nonetheless allowed the powers to lapse over the summer. (Emphasis mine)
There are many other members of Congress in the House and the Senate — from both parties — who are on board with increasing government warrantless spying on Americans, including: Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ), Sen. James Lankford (R-OK), Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA), and Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX). Cornyn has been a cheerleader of FISA Section 702 for years and, in a recent Wall Street Journal op-ed, defended it as an “indispensable tool”, and he wants “Congress to reauthorize this vital tool during the lame-duck session” (via cornyn.senate.gov):
Congress needs to act on a crucial intelligence authority that has expired and may soon go dark. Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which CIA Director John Ratcliffe has called “an indispensable national-security tool,” lapsed in June. While parts of the authority remain in place to prevent catastrophe, Congress can’t put off the issue.
The authority is powerful, but narrow. Section 702 can be used only to target foreigners abroad who have information on specific foreign-intelligence topics: foreign governments, counterterrorism, proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, and international narcotics trafficking. It can never be used to target U.S. citizens or people in the U.S.
That doesn’t mean Americans are never affected. The most debated aspect of Section 702 is “U.S.-person queries,” in which analysts—in limited circumstances—can use an American’s name or other identifying details to retrieve data incidentally but lawfully collected under Section 702.
All the same, these queries raise important questions for civil liberties. In the past, some FBI agents ran queries that didn’t comply with program rules. Most of the errors stemmed from misunderstanding the rules, not malice, but any noncompliance is unacceptable when Americans’ personal data is involved. (Emphasis mine)
In summary, FISA Section 702 can’t be used to “target” Americans, but it can be used to “retrieve data incidentally but lawfully.” And even when the police state runs queries that don’t comply with the rules, it was all just a misunderstanding.
Well… since it only happens “incidentally” or by accident, I guess we can just ignore the Fourth Amendment.
Even though both Republicans and Democrats are pushing for a clean FISA Section 702 renewal, the clock is ticking on Trump and his Republican buddies to get this done during the lame duck session. Not to worry though, Senate Appropriation Chair Mike Rounds (R-SD) is ready to add it to the must-pass National Defense Authorization Act.
You remember the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), don’t you? It’s the legislation that contains in Section 219 — formerly Section 224 before the House passed and changed it in July — a provision known as the “United States-Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative” that will “integrate” the US Military with the Israeli military. Talk about a win-win.
Do you remember the USA FREEDOM Act? It was a law pushed by Mike Lee back in 2015 in response to NSA spying under FISA and was supposed to reign in government’s blatant abuse of power. When the legislation passed, it was supposed to bring an end to bulk collection of metadata by the NSA and rein in the FISA Court, but it didn’t.
In the end, the FREEDOM Act failed, the NSA continued spying, the FISA Court kept all its power after Trump and the Republican-controlled Congress approved the “periodic congressional reauthorization” of FISA Section 702 in 2018 until December 2023 — putting it past the 2020 presidential campaign — when Mike Johnson and the Republican Party controlling the House at the time joined Joe Biden and the Democrats to reauthorize FISA 702 until April 2026, which brings us to our current debate.
Though FISA originated during the Cold War to gather foreign intelligence information, the current debate over Section 702 began around 2008, when Republicans joined the Democrat majority to legalize a surveillance program secretly created by the National Security Agency after 9/11. FISA Section 702 allows our government overlords to track the electronic communications of foreign terrorists, spies, and hackers without obtaining a warrant, but it has also provided government with communications data from an unknown number of Americans.
As I document in Chapter 8 of my book, The New Axis of Evil: Exposing the Bipartisan War on Liberty, FISA Section 702 is just one of the boatloads of liberty-killing laws passed by Congress and signed into law by George W. Bush post-9/11. And despite the rhetoric coming out of Washington from both parties, this war is likely to continue.
Democrats and Republicans want to cram FISA Section renewal down the throats of Americans during the lame duck session of Congress. The only question is this: will we let them do it or will we demand that warrantless government spying come to an end? The choice is yours, America.
David Leach is the owner of the Strident Conservative. He holds people of every political stripe accountable for their failure to uphold conservative values, and he promotes those values instead of political parties. He the author of The New Axis of Evil: Exposing the Bipartisan War on Liberty.
Follow the Strident Conservative on Twitter and Facebook.
Subscribe to receive podcasts of his daily radio feature: iTunes | Pandora | Tune In | iHeart | RSS
For media inquiries or to have David speak to your group, use the Contact Us form.
